From the Judge’s Chair

I had the opportunity to be one of the judges at this year’s 36th International Kuo Shu Championship Tournament. I was assigned to events held for Adults: Beginner, Intermediate and Advance. All were hand forms and a variety of styles were performed. I also judged Adult Senior Tai Ji Form Men/Women 40-59 years as well as 60 years and over. There was a wide range of experience which was demonstrated in their performances.

What remained constant from a judges point of view was whether Tai Chi principles were being adhered too. Not knowing what each school emphasizes in their programs and when a student is capable of understanding and incorporating them in their form, differentiates those who place and those who do not.

There were beginners and intermediates who demonstrated a better understanding than some advanced students. There is also the experience of the judges and their own knowledge and adherence to the Tai Chi principles that influence the scores they provide. It’s impossible to be objective and our subjective biases affect what each judge is focused on which is why 3-5 pair of eyes in necessary.

To compete takes dedication, time and commitment. Stepping into the ring also takes courage and the willingness to be judged by others. All the time spent in preparation comes down to 3.5 minutes and the opinions of 3-5 individuals you don’t know. Regardless of the outcome, competitors should come away with a greater appreciation for why they study this art form in the first place. It should also be the impetus to step back into the ring next year.

Jeffrey Peezick